| NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL | |||
| ALL-AMERICAN | |||
| Team Honors | |||
| YEAR | PLAYER | POSITION | TEAM |
| 1985 | Gary Wellman | Running Back | Adidas Honorable Mention |
| 1990 | Todd Preston | Quarterback | Super Prep Magazine |
| 1994 | Billy Miller | Wide Receiver | Reebok |
| Schutt | |||
| Parade Magazine | |||
| ESPN | |||
| Super Prep Magazine | |||
| Blue Chip Magazine | |||
| College Sports Magazine | |||
| USA Today 2nd Team | |||
| 1996 | Bobby DeMars | Linebacker | Schutt |
| 1997 | Mike Seidman | Student Sport Magazine (Junior Team) | |
| Zac Wasserman | Student Sport Magazine (Sophomore Team) | ||
| 1998 | Mike Seidman | Tight End | Chopat |
| Coach Magazine | |||
| Player Magazine | |||
| Parade Magazine | |||
| USA Today | |||
| Super Prep Magazine | |||
| Blue Chip Magazine | |||
| 1999 | Zac Wasserman | Quarterback | Parade Magazine |
| Student Sports Magazine | |||
| 2000 | Ryan Foltz | Defensive Back | Student Sports Magazine |
| 2003 | Jimmy Miller | Defensive Line | Super Prep Magazine |
| Prep Star Magazine | |||
| Michael Stuart | Wide Receiver | Super Prep Magazine | |
| Prep Star Magazine | |||
| 2009 | Justin Solis | Defensive Line | Maxpreps (Sophomore Team) |
| 2010 | Nick Isham | Quarterback | Old Spice |
| 2011 | Dashon Hunt | Defensive Back | U.S. Air Force |
| 2012 | |||
| Westlake High School Football | |||
