| DAILY NEWS | |||
| All-Area Teams | |||
| YEAR | PLAYER | POSITION | TEAM |
| 1979 | Bill Turner | Punter | 1st Team |
| Rusty Weber | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| John Fasano | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 1980 | Bill Turner | Fullback | 2nd Team |
| Nick Kormanik | Defensive Line | 1st Team | |
| 1981 | Glenn Wellman | Running Back | 2nd Team |
| Craig Slavin | Linebacker | ||
| 1982 | Craig Slavin | Linebacker | 1st Team |
| Bill Fiander | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| Jamin McNeil | Running Back | 1st Team | |
| Dave Baille | Defensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| 1983 | Jim Grandpre | Defensive Back | 2nd Team |
| 1985 | Brad Gossen | Quarterback | 1st Team |
| Gary Wellman | Running Back | 1st Team | |
| Scott Ford | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| 1988 | Keith Burke | Running Back | 2nd Team |
| 1989 | Seamus Gibbons | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| 1990 | Todd Preston | Quarterback | 1st Team |
| Seamus Gibbons | Wide Receiver | 1st Team | |
| Dave Monheim | Tight End | 2nd Team | |
| 1991 | Erik Holcomb | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| 1992 | Rob Kaller | Offensive Line | 2nd Team |
| 1993 | Billy Miller | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| Mike Tetzlaff | Defensive End | 2nd Team | |
| 1994 | Billy Miller | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| Eric Guenther | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| 1995 | Bobby DeMars | Linebacker | 2nd Team |
| Jamal Harris | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 1996 | Joey Cuppari | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| Bobby DeMars | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| Jonathan Weems | Running Back | 2nd Team | |
| Jeremy Golden | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 1997 | Joey Cuppari | Wide Receiver | 1st Team |
| 1998 | Mike Seidman | Tight End | 1st Team |
| Zac Wasserman | Quarterback | 2nd Team | |
| Julian Lambert | Running Back | 2nd Team | |
| Travis Campbell | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 1999 | Zac Wasserman | Quarterback | Player of the Year |
| Chris Catalano | Defensive Back | 1st Team | |
| Michael Brignac | Wide Receiver | 1st Team | |
| Jordan Lampos | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| Keith Holt | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| 2000 | Ryan Foltz | Defensive Back | Defensive Player of the Year |
| Mark Manning | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Jonathan Contos | Running Back | 1st Team | |
| 2001 | Steve Hall | Offensive Line | 1st Team |
| Jonathan Contos | Running Back | 1st Team | |
| Chris Cannon | Defensive Back | Honorable Mention | |
| 2002 | Jimmy Miller | Defensive Line | 1st Team |
| Michael Stuart | Defensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Zach Verdin | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Merrill Mullaly | Running Back | 2nd Team | |
| Greg Newman | Linebacker | 2nd Team | |
| Eric Vose | Quarterback | Honorable Mention | |
| Kenneth Mackins | Defensive Back | Honorable Mention | |
| 2003 | Rudy Carpenter | Quarterback | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Greg Newman | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| Ryan Sorensen | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Michael Stuart | Defensive End | 1st Team | |
| Tahj Mowry | Running Back | 2nd Team | |
| Steve Gatena | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| Marcus Maddocks | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 2006 | Jordan Mannisto | Kicker | 1st Team |
| Tyrone Duncan | Defensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| Michael Streck-Woodard | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2007 | Byron Sells | Defensive Back | Honorable Mention |
| Ryan Campbell | Quarterback | Honorable Mention | |
| David Ruelas | Offensive Line | Honorable Mention | |
| Jordan Mannisto | Kicker | 1st Team | |
| Justin Lilley | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| 2008 | Curtis Peterson | Wide Receiver | 2nd Team |
| Tommy Doupe | Defensive End | Honorable Mention | |
| Nick Owens | Quarterback | Honorable Mention | |
| Cooper Shockley | Running Back | Honorable Mention | |
| Justin Lilley | Defensive Back | 1st Team | |
| James DeLaCerna | Wide Receiver | Honorable Mention | |
| Spencer Christiansen | Center | Honorable Mention | |
| Steve Hagy | Wide Receiver | Honorable Mention | |
| 2009 | Nick Isham | Quarterback | 1st Team |
| Nelson Spruce | Wide Receiver | 1st Team | |
| Michael Lorenzo | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| Alex Ball | Kicker | 2nd Team | |
| Adrian Muguerza | Linebacker | 2nd Team | |
| 2010 | Nick Isham | Quarterback | Player of the Year |
| Nelson Spruce | Wide Receiver | 1st Team | |
| Justin Solis | Defensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Casey Bliss | Defensive Back | 1st Team | |
| Max Winsberg | Linebacker | 2nd Team | |
| Dashon Hunt | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | |
| Anthony Davanzo | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| Alex Ball | Kicker | 2nd Team | |
| 2011 | Justin Moore | Quarterback | Player of the Year |
| Anthony Davanzo | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Keith Ramljak | Offensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Alex Ball | Kicker | 1st Team | |
| David Ortiz | Linebacker | 1st Team | |
| Johnny Stuart | Defensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Justin Solis | Defensive Line | 1st Team | |
| Jordie Hannel | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | |
| Cody Tuttle | Wide Receiver | 2nd Team | |
| 2012 | |||
| Westlake High School Football | |||
